Katharine McPhee Just Stirred Up Some Serious American Idol Drama from 2006

If you were a pre-teen in 2006, you probably hold up the American Idol season 5 finale as a defining moment of your youth, perhaps the instance in which you realized that sometimes, just sometimes, the underdog really does come out on top. Just me? OK, fine.

Click Here: Cardiff Blues Store

On that iconic evening in late May, prematurely gray singer Taylor Hicks was crowned 2006’s American Idol, beating out fan-favorite Katharine McPhee.

Now 34, McPhee — who bears absolutely zero resentment whatsoever regarding the finale upset — has moved on (she’s got a hit Broadway play, a network TV show and an engagement under her belt, so we’d say she’s doing just fine). Instead of stewing on her loss from over a decade ago, she’s spending her time encouraging her fans and followers to vote in the upcoming midterm elections on Tuesday. 

To get the word out, she tweeted a photo of Hicks receiving his crowning title alongside good sport McPhee, adding the (not even slightly salty) caption: “voting matters.”

FYI, I vividly recall whipping out my pink Razr and texting my vote for Hicks that week, so some of us did vote for *our* American Idol, Kat.

RELATED: Katharine McPhee’s Engagement Ring Reveal on Instagram Is a Bittersweet Moment

Anyway, Mr. Hicks wasn’t about to let that sick burn slide on his watch. The Alabama native responded to McPhee’s diss: “You’re right, voting DOES matter! But you’re a little late to the party, Kat.” He also tweeted out a link to a voter registration video he posted on Facebook five months ago.

Zing!